Dis or Dat?

As many of you know, I've been on an endless quest for an office rug.

I've had lovely, but too small:

And, kind of cool, but knit like a sweater:

So, I finally found this cute rug (in blue):

While waiting for this rug to arrive, I put down a rug that was in my former apartment in NYC. Here's a photo of it then:

It's really soft and I've gotten used to it...so perhaps I had the rug all along and didn't realize it! It's decision time...I must stop the madness and move on! Which do you prefer?

New rug in office space:

Old rug in office space:

I've got to get some window treatments up so perhaps the decision will come down to what type of wonderful fabric I can come up with after a quick trip to Calico Corners. More to come, but I think it may actually come together soon!

P.S. Due to my not-so-great photography skills, I'm afraid the lighting doesn't do the old rug justice here!